Get the top HN stories in your inbox every day.
notepad0x90
hdgvhicv
I use apache guacamole for this with our OIDC proxy for this purpose
notepad0x90
I've used it before, setting it up wasn't pleasant with the whole java/tomcat thing, and it kept having severe vulnerabilities.
MaKey
FYI, Azure Bastion is based on Apache Guacamole. You're paying them for not having to manage your own instance.
mcoliver
With hp shutting down anyware / teradici / pcoip there are quite a few people looking for alternatives that support high resolution multi monitor with 60fps high bit depth playback and things like wacom tablet support and all three OS. Parsec and DCV are out there on the spend money side. I'm excited about the open source efforts. Things like rustdesk,kyber, and teraguchi. The community needs an open source high performance option.
https://github.com/rustdesk/rustdesk
https://github.com/thedepartmentofexternalservices/teraguchi
miniman1337
FWIW DCV is free on EC2, and anywhere else it has a very minimal nag without a license.
solarkraft
Looks very interesting, but i’m a bit surprised the most important feature isn’t mentioned: How well does clipboard sharing work?
wcrossbow
Im not a big fan of Windows but copy pasting a file across 3 nested RDP sessions feels magical every time
hypercube33
It actually doesn't it feels horrible. you can't paste files from a samba share or large ones take so long to copy that they ultimately fail.
ktpsns
To be honest, three nested RDPs sound like a terrible hack. In an ideal world, this would be two port forwardings and one RDP (thinking about ssh, which is still underrepresented in windows world). In an even more ideal world, this would be an IPv6 direct access ;-)
everforward
There are legit reasons, at least for two nested sessions. A production network that’s airgapped except for a bastion host that acts as a gateway. It’s better than port forwarding because you have to auth to the bastion host before the RDP chaining, and it often takes separate credentials for the second RDP session.
It’s a semi-common setup for higher security environments, and when you have a network of stuff that has known vulnerabilities you can’t patch for whatever reason. Traffic in and out is super carefully firewalled. It’s not great, but it’s better than a 25 year old MySQL with a direct public IP.
orisho
It's probably there not as a way to connect networks, but as a way to keep them separate, only allowing RDP between specific computers on different networks.
debarshri
I am not sure if you have tried broadcasting feature in terminals, thats magical too.
debarshri
We have a custom RDP client [1]. So i have some experience building something like this. We do some an implementation similar to this.
Clipboard sharing, uploading and downloading via shared drive is a freerdp feature that should be readily available.
We also have sessions recording which is non-negotiable in PAM.
d3Xt3r
And desktop scaling. And multi-monitor support. And file transfers. And drive redirection. And peripheral redirection. And...
rvz
...A test suite, And security audits, And most importantly benchmarks.
What it does have is a license which it is GPLv3. So if anyone adds all those changes, they have to make the source code available with the same software license.
pixel_popping
In this era tho, licenses (I don't agree with this, but this is what it is) are a matter of "tokens", I speak for a fact knowing multiple relatively-big companies just gobbling GPLv3 projects and rewriting them entirely, some do publish them as well.
yamapikarya
is it work for opening rdp file from cyberark pam?
igtztorrero
Does Alt-Tab inside the Browser Tab can be hooked to the rdp client ???
That was the main problem in guacamole rdp in browser.
jqpabc123
Interesting from a technical perspective but with native RDP clients readily available on just about every platform, I don't see the need for it.
le-mark
When it’s in a browser you don’t need to install anything on the local machine. I used to use Apache guacamole to access my machine at home from work when I was stuck in a cube all day.
stephbook
1 contributor, 1 commit, new project... gives me vibe-coding feels.
zcw100
If you have factual observations to make that's fine but can we stop with the "smells like vibe coding" attacks? It's like an AI version of an ad-hominem attack.
pixel_popping
Browsers are sandboxes, your native client often isn't, there is definitely a huge advantage, portability and embeddability as well, it's also simpler to sniff traffic (and MITM it).
jqpabc123
Doesn't this limit your ability to share resources and transfer data?
pixel_popping
Why would it? You have access to your entire filesystem via the browser.
boredishBoi
Not many good MFA options for native RDP/RDG. Putting it in the browser lets you wrap the whole thing with OAUTH/passkeys etc
hnlmorg
Having just implemented OAUTH into a Go app this week, I can assure you that it’s surprising easy to do so without making your entire application a website.
boredishBoi
I don’t disagree but none of the native RDP clients support oauth for non azure computers.
tom_alexander
Perhaps as a web client for the remote desktop on the BMC chips?
the_data_nerd
[flagged]
maxloh
> ...on the read side most browsers prompt the user every single time.
I don't think that is the case. Google Docs, Office 365, and Notion all function without requiring repeated user permissions.
socalgal2
Google Docs has the same issue. They ask you to install of Google Docs Offline chrome extension to fix it.
https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/google-docs-offline...
> Note: This extension is also used to make advanced copy & paste functionality available in Google Docs, Sheets and Slides.
jerrythegerbil
I can assure you they’ve correctly described the problem and are correct regarding buffering and user gesture requirements.
The platforms you listed are all primarily text-based and the interaction lives in the DOM with happy paths defined. Still, you will find that clipboard media with a MIME type will prompt you with a Google provided modal to paste a very specific way to get around the permissions model in Google Docs etc…
An RDP interface is not a text box with features on top, the standing expectations for those existing behaviors do not apply. Namely clipboard, and any I/O for that matter. For example, the linked repo uses a protocol bridge (I/O) to support the RDP protocol from a browser, because “the browser speaks protocols” is a true general statement, but absolutely doesn’t apply when you actually need to get something non-trivial done.
At its core, when someone points to the Google Chrome desktop icon and says “that’s the internet” there’s really no point in discussing the nuance in most cases, because anything non-trivial immediately invalidates that understanding of the world and reaching that point organically is far more important than it being explained to them preemptively.
They are correct, because the nuance applies. Welcome to the un-happy path!
hawk_
There's something about keyboard shortcuts - they work. But somehow right-click and copy requires add-ons.
sebakubisz
[dead]
xiaod
[dead]
johnwhitman
[dead]
Get the top HN stories in your inbox every day.
This is cool. If it adds session recording and SSO auth support, it can be used as an RDP jumphost.
I've used Azure bastion to do just this, you auth to the azure portal using whatever authentication regime is configured for your tenant, then you rdp into virtual machines from your browser using the local vm login. it handles things like files and clipboards great. But it also supports console sessions in the browser.
I haven't used it with windows/rdp (if it even is supported), but in GCP, their in-browser SSH is the best I've seen so far.
Even for Linux, I've found xrdp to be better than alternatives at times.
The main problem I see this solving (one of many) is the decoupling of the management interface for virtual machines and servers from their service interfaces. not having your web server's management services on the same IP/domain/interface as the http server is a big improvement. Lots of security screw-ups happen because of this entanglement.